AdvertiseDonate
DetroitToledoClevelandFort WayneColumbusPittsburghBuffaloCincinnati
Journal Orbit · 2751 E Jefferson Ave, Suite 400, Detroit, MI 48207

Campaigners label Cop31 draft agreement the worst in history

Climate justice advocates criticize the latest text from the Turkey summit for removing key fossil fuel phase-out commitments and prioritizing carbon capture technologies.

By Jessica Peterson ·

Illustration for: Campaigners label Cop31 draft agreement the worst in history
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Climate justice campaigners have issued a strong criticism of the draft outcome from the Cop31 climate summit in Turkey, describing the document as the weakest in the history of the global talks. The draft agreement, which serves as the overarching text summarizing negotiation outcomes, has been significantly altered since its initial release on Monday. Many of the central commitments, including specific targets for finance and a clear transition away from fossil fuels, have been removed from the latest version.

The most notable change involves the language regarding fossil fuels. The previous commitment to transition away from these energy sources has been replaced with a pledge to achieve an irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience. While this shift may appear subtle, industry observers argue it represents a significant step backward for developing nations and a move that favors the private sector and fossil fuel industries.

Harjeet Singh, a strategic adviser to the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative, described the new language as aggressive and backward-looking. He noted that the text does not assist developing countries as intended but instead benefits the fossil fuel industry. This sentiment was echoed by other civil society actors who view the changes as a retreat from the goals established by the Paris Agreement.

A major point of contention in the new draft is the emphasis on carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies. The text pledges to increase these technologies by a factor of 20 to 40 by the year 2035. Critics have derided this approach as a false solution to climate breakdown, arguing that it provides the fossil fuel industry with an excuse to continue expanding drilling and production.

Andreas Sieber, head of political strategy at 350.org, highlighted the unreliability and high cost of these technologies. He pointed out that most carbon capture projects initiated in the last three decades have failed. Furthermore, he noted that approximately 80 percent of such projects are linked to new fossil fuel operations, where they only slightly reduce emissions rather than neutralizing them entirely. He described these projects as a fig leaf for continued fossil fuel expansion.

Negotiations regarding climate finance also yielded weak results for developing nations. The final text no longer mentions Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement, which obligates developed countries to provide financial resources for mitigation and adaptation. Additionally, a reference to tripling climate adaptation funding by 2035, a target set at the previous summit in Belem, Brazil, was removed. Any mention of the historical responsibility of developed nations has also been stripped from the document.

Saudi Arabia has emerged as a primary actor in blocking references to a fossil fuel phase-out. The kingdom has held multiple meetings with the Cop presidency, consistently pushing for weaker language on fossil fuels and the inclusion of specific targets for carbon capture and storage. These efforts have shaped the direction of the final text, according to sources familiar with the discussions.

On the issue of finance, campaigners are pointing to developed countries, particularly the European Union, Australia, and Norway, for their strong pushback. The EU had previously declared fresh climate finance pledges dead in the water before the conference began. This stance has left developing regions struggling to secure the necessary funds to cope with rising sea levels, fires, droughts, and heat waves.

Henan Keskes of Greenpeace Mena emphasized that climate finance is a matter of survival for the region. She stated that the area receives a very small portion of the necessary funds for mitigation and adaptation. The lack of progress in this area is seen as a major failure of the summit in addressing the immediate needs of vulnerable populations.

The operationalization of a Just Transition mechanism, agreed upon at the previous Cop30, also faced significant resistance. This framework aims to support workers and protect communities as nations shift away from fossil fuel-based economies. The same set of countries that resisted finance pledges also pushed back on defining this mechanism further. Singh called this outcome unacceptable, reinforcing the campaign group's view that this is the worst Cop in history because the final text fails to deliver meaningful support.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. T-Mobile’s Outsourcing Strategy Is Eroding the Trust of American Customers
  2. New Evidence Leads to Murder Charges in South Carolina Road Rage Case
  3. Top Online Sportsbooks Offer Nearly $4,000 in NBA Betting Promos for Nov. 20
  4. NWSL Championship Matchup Highlights Ongoing Expansion of Women's Soccer
  5. Week 12 College Football: Key Matchups and Betting Lines for the Weekend
Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.