Florida Mechanic Convicted in the Stabbing Death of British Teacher
A jury in Florida has found a mechanic guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping in the case of a British woman who traveled to the US after posting about her desire to die.
By Jessica Peterson ·

Dwain Hall, a Florida auto repair technician and tow truck driver, has been found guilty of stabbing to death Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music teacher from Portsmouth, England. The verdict concludes a trial in which Hall faced charges of first-degree murder and kidnapping. He had previously pleaded not guilty to both counts.
The prosecution alleged that Hall groomed Exelby through a fetish website before convincing her to travel to the United States. Investigators stated that Exelby, who suffered from mental illness, had posted online about wanting someone to end her life. Authorities claimed Hall was aware of her suicidal thoughts and used her vulnerability to lure her to Florida.
Exelby arrived in the US in October 2025. According to law enforcement, Hall picked her up from the airport in Gainesville, central Florida. He then drove her to an Airbnb rental. Investigators later recovered evidence at that location, including a video of Exelby on Hall’s cellphone and records of transactions made on her bank cards, which they say linked him to her disappearance.
During the trial, jurors heard testimony primarily from law enforcement officials. These witnesses detailed Hall’s movements by tracing his email correspondence, phone records, and social media activity following Exelby’s arrival. The disappearance of Exelby from her home in England had triggered an international investigation into the case.
Prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt argued that Hall targeted Exelby specifically because of her mental health struggles. She described the victim as beautiful, kind, and deeply loved by those who knew her, while noting she had suffered from mental illness for most of her life. Berndt urged the jury to use their common sense, stating that Hall killed Exelby for his sadistic pleasure and that no one else could have saved her from him.
Berndt referred to Hall as an Alpha Sadist who took advantage of a severely depressed woman who was incapable of making rational decisions. She emphasized that Exelby should be alive today, highlighting the tragedy of her loss to the family and community.
In his closing statement, Hall’s attorney, Junior Barrett, contended that Exelby had taken her own life. Barrett argued that she came to the US with the intention of dying because she viewed herself as worthless and a burden on others. He told the jury that the case should not be decided based on dislike of Hall’s lifestyle or the specific pornography he enjoyed.
Barrett maintained that the fact Hall did not stop Exelby from killing herself did not automatically constitute murder. He suggested that the jury focus on her intent rather than the defendant's preferences.
Following the verdict, Barry Wilton, Exelby’s brother, spoke about the profound impact of the loss on his family. He described the past year as one of the hardest of their lives and expressed uncertainty about whether the family would ever be the same again.
Wilton also addressed Hall directly, stating that the mechanic had pretended to care for Sonia but instead used her to fulfill his sick fantasies. Wilton said Hall had her life in his hands and had the opportunity to save her, but he chose to prey on her vulnerabilities and take her from them.






