AdvertiseDonate
DetroitToledoClevelandFort WayneColumbusPittsburghBuffaloCincinnati
Journal Orbit · 2751 E Jefferson Ave, Suite 400, Detroit, MI 48207
News · Lake County

Former Deputy Convicted of Killing Teen, Facing Up to 10 Years in Prison

Matthew Herpstreith, 46, was found guilty of reckless homicide and other charges in the death of Jackson Kradle, 18, on a rural highway.

By Kevin Koch ·

Illustration for: Former Deputy Convicted of Killing Teen, Facing Up to 10 Years in Prison
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Matthew Herpstreith, 46, was led out of the Carroll County courtroom in handcuffs on Wednesday evening after a jury found him guilty of causing the death of an 18-year-old teen two years ago. The former sheriff's deputy, who resides in Savanna, faced a Class 3 felony charge of reckless homicide that carries a potential prison sentence of up to ten years.

The jury also returned guilty verdicts on three additional counts. Herpstreith was found guilty of reckless conduct and obstructing justice, both Class 4 felonies, as well as attempting to obstruct justice by destroying evidence, a Class A misdemeanor. A petty offense for failure to reduce speed to avoid an accident was also included in the verdict read by Ogle County Associate Judge Anthony Peska.

Jackson Kradle's body was discovered at 3:30 a.m. on July 28, 2024, on Route 78 less than a mile north of Mount Carroll. Forensic pathologist Mark Peters testified that Kradle was lying face down when struck. His injuries were consistent with being run over and partially dragged by the vehicle's undercarriage. Peters noted that the direction of the injuries indicated the vehicle passed over Kradle from feet to head, with no signs of tire impact.

Accident reconstructionist Zachary Bingen created a digital model of the crash to assess visibility. He testified that in ideal daylight, a driver traveling at the 55 mph speed limit would see a body from 300 feet away. Under the dark, rainy conditions described by witnesses, the body would not have been visible until the truck was 80 to 85 feet away if high beams were off. Bingen stated that in all scenarios, it was very unlikely the driver would miss the body completely.

Special Prosecutor Charles Colburn told jurors to look at the totality of circumstances, pointing to security footage from a Savanna car wash. The video, captured between 4:03 and 4:07 a.m. on the night of the crash, showed Herpstreith pressure washing the undercarriage of his truck. Colburn argued that Herpstreith knew he hit Kradle and was trying to destroy evidence.

Defense attorney Joseph Nack countered that Herpstreith admitted to washing the car to remove blood splatter from the road. Nack stated that the prosecution lacked evidence of alcohol consumption or specific driving errors. He argued that if Herpstreith wanted to hide evidence, he would have simply driven away instead of washing the vehicle. The defense also noted that Kradle had alcohol and marijuana in his system at the time of death.

Herpstreith was not detained on a bond for the two and a half years leading up to the trial. The jury began deliberations at 3:24 p.m. Wednesday and reached its decision at 7:05 p.m. He is currently held in the Carroll County jail. A hearing on prosecutors' motion for post-conviction detention is set for 9 a.m. Thursday, with sentencing tentatively scheduled for January 22, 2027.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. T-Mobile’s Outsourcing Strategy Is Eroding the Trust of American Customers
  2. New Evidence Leads to Murder Charges in South Carolina Road Rage Case
  3. Top Online Sportsbooks Offer Nearly $4,000 in NBA Betting Promos for Nov. 20
  4. NWSL Championship Matchup Highlights Ongoing Expansion of Women's Soccer
  5. Week 12 College Football: Key Matchups and Betting Lines for the Weekend
Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.