AdvertiseDonate
DetroitToledoClevelandFort WayneColumbusPittsburghBuffaloCincinnati
Journal Orbit · 2751 E Jefferson Ave, Suite 400, Detroit, MI 48207

Home Depot and Lowe's earnings highlight the struggle in a stagnant housing market

Home Depot outperformed Lowe's in key metrics this quarter, driven by a stronger professional customer base, despite a challenging housing market and elevated interest rates.

By Vanessa Diaz ·

Illustration for: Home Depot and Lowe's earnings highlight the struggle in a stagnant housing market
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Earnings reports released this week by Home Depot and Lowe's underscored that neither major home improvement retailer is likely to receive immediate relief from a sluggish housing market and elevated interest rates. Consequently, the competitive dynamic between the two companies remains focused on internal operational efficiency and revenue stability. Market observers continue to favor Home Depot due to its stronger reliance on professional customers, a segment that offers a more durable income stream and positions the company advantageously for when economic conditions improve.

Home Depot demonstrated a clear lead in several key financial metrics during its fiscal third quarter. The company reported a same-store sales growth of 2.2%, outpacing Lowe's 1.8% gain. Revenue for Home Depot reached 43.4 billion dollars, significantly higher than Lowe's 22.8 billion dollars. Additionally, Home Depot posted a 3.2% increase in earnings per share, compared to a 1.3% rise for its competitor. The operating margin for Home Depot was 12.6%, surpassing Lowe's 11.3%.

Despite a strong quarterly performance, Home Depot shares reacted negatively to the results. Jim Cramer, a prominent financial commentator, suggested that investors should view the stock dip as a buying opportunity. He argued on his program that the market's negative response stemmed from a short-sighted interpretation of the company's updated guidance. Cramer noted that Home Depot is historically conservative in its forecasts, a strategy that becomes even more prudent with a new chief executive officer taking the helm.

Alongside its financial results, Home Depot announced significant leadership changes. CFO Richard McPhail is set to succeed Ted Decker as CEO next week. Decker, who has been on temporary medical leave since August, will transition to the role of chairman of the board. Jordan Broggi will assume the position of executive vice president and CFO, while Ann-Marie Campbell, who helped lead the company during Decker's absence, will become president and chief operating officer.

During the post-earnings conference call, McPhail stated that investments across various business units are resonating well with customers, particularly the professional segment. Campbell added that all professional customer cohorts recorded positive same-store sales growth. This included both pros shopping in-store and larger pros engaged in complex projects who utilized the company's expanded ecosystem capabilities. Although professional customers outperformed do-it-yourself shoppers, both segments posted positive growth for the quarter.

Lowe's reported a solid quarter on Wednesday and raised its guidance, citing strength among professional customers, which led to an increase in its stock price. Analysts at D.A. Davidson noted that Lowe's experienced sequential improvement in comp sales for both DIY and pro customers, though only the pro segment showed positive growth compared to the previous year. The company attributed its gains in the small-to-medium professional cohort to deeper customer relationships, improved fulfillment, and enhanced loyalty options.

Both retailers are aggressively courting the professional customer base, though their acquisition strategies have differed in timing. Home Depot moved quickly to expand its distribution operations by purchasing three specialty building products companies over the last three years. These acquisitions include SRS in 2024, GMS in 2025, and Mingledorff's in 2026. Lowe's followed suit last year with the acquisitions of Artisan Design Group and Foundation Building Materials.

The broader macroeconomic environment remains challenging for both companies. Both stocks recently bounced off their 2026 lows, a move that coincided with the peak in the 10-year Treasury yield, which influences mortgage rates. Elevated mortgage rates continue to suppress housing activity, which is vital for both renovation and new construction sectors. While both stocks have cooled in recent weeks, Home Depot shares have declined less than Lowe's on a year-to-date basis.

Cramer acknowledged that investing in Home Depot over the past few years has been difficult, with rate outlooks frequently reversing. Sticky inflation has increased the likelihood of additional Federal Reserve rate hikes in the coming months, adding to the uncertainty. However, Cramer remains confident that Home Depot is the best positioned to benefit when rates eventually decline and the housing market recovers. He predicted that the stock, currently trading at 339 dollars, will eventually reach 500 dollars, a view supported by a buy-equivalent rating and a 370 dollar price target from his team.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. T-Mobile’s Outsourcing Strategy Is Eroding the Trust of American Customers
  2. New Evidence Leads to Murder Charges in South Carolina Road Rage Case
  3. Top Online Sportsbooks Offer Nearly $4,000 in NBA Betting Promos for Nov. 20
  4. NWSL Championship Matchup Highlights Ongoing Expansion of Women's Soccer
  5. Week 12 College Football: Key Matchups and Betting Lines for the Weekend
Get Journal Orbit in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.