Judge Keeps Alex Murdaugh Double Murder Indictment Intact
A South Carolina judge denied defense motions to dismiss charges, ruling that other evidence sufficiently supported the case despite errors in forensic testimony.
By Kevin Koch ·

Alex Murdaugh has received a significant setback in his legal battle as a South Carolina judge refused to dismiss the double murder indictment against him. This ruling occurs just months before his scheduled retrial, marking another hurdle for the former attorney in his ongoing legal proceedings.
On Friday, November 13, defense attorneys argued during a pre-trial hearing that the state's lead investigator, Special Agent David Owen of the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, provided misleading testimony. They claimed his statements regarding blood spatter and shotgun ammunition undermined the integrity of the grand jury process.
Circuit Court Judge Debra R. McCaslin issued her decision that same afternoon. She acknowledged that the state made major errors in how it presented evidence to the grand jurors. However, she concluded that the remaining unchallenged evidence was strong enough to establish probable cause for the indictment.
Judge McCaslin wrote that even if the disputed testimony about blood spatter on a T-shirt and shotgun ammunition were removed from consideration, the other evidence overwhelmingly supported the charges. She noted that while the court does not take lightly the investigator's failure to account for a laboratory report addressed to him, the oversight was not intentional.
The judge criticized Agent Owen for not recognizing and accounting for a lab report before testifying. She stated that such oversights can undermine public confidence in the criminal justice system. Nevertheless, she found no evidence of intentional fabrication or prosecutorial misconduct in the record.
The defense had focused on two main points of contention. First, they argued that Owen misled the grand jury about blood spatter found on the shirt Murdaugh wore when his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, were killed at their property in Colleton County on June 7, 2021. Owen claimed this spatter linked Murdaugh to the killings, despite earlier tests failing to detect human blood in samples from the garment.
Second, the defense challenged Owen's claim that shotguns found on the property were loaded with the same combination of ammunition used to kill Paul. Murdaugh's attorneys maintained that none of the recovered shotguns contained the exact combination of shells found at the scene. Prosecutors countered that the description was imprecise but reflected the investigators' understanding at the time.
Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters stated that the testimony was not overtly false. Prosecutors also pointed to additional testing by a state expert, which suggested that earlier chemical treatment of the shirt could have produced false negative results for blood. The expert stands by his conclusions, and prosecutors argue Owen accurately captured the investigators' understanding of the evidence during the grand jury proceedings.
Judge McCaslin indicated that the defense can challenge these disputed evidentiary points during the trial itself. She explained that inconsistencies in forensic conclusions are best addressed through cross-examination and impeachment at trial rather than through a pre-trial dismissal of valid indictments.
The South Carolina Attorney General's Office responded to the ruling by stating that they continue to prepare for the retrial. Murdaugh was originally convicted of both murders in 2023, but the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned those convictions after finding that the former Colleton County Clerk of Court had improperly influenced the jury. His retrial is set to begin on April 5, 2027.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






