Polling reveals persistent doubts about midterm fairness among Republican voters
New data indicates that while President Trump initially accepted election results, a majority of GOP voters still question the integrity of the 2026 midterms.
By Jessica Peterson ·

President Donald Trump appeared to accept the outcome of his party's midterm defeats, yet new data suggests that significant skepticism remains within the Republican base regarding the election process. A poll released on Friday by the University of California San Diego reveals that broad distrust in the integrity of the vote persists among conservative voters, even after the initial concession.
According to the new findings, fewer than half of Republican voters nationwide believed the midterm elections were conducted in a free and fair manner. Specifically, only 52 percent of Republicans expressed confidence that their votes were counted accurately. This figure stands in sharp contrast to the sentiment observed after the 2024 election, which Trump won. At that time, more than 80 percent of Republicans reported having confidence in the vote-counting process.
Election experts note that while trust often declines among the losing party, the magnitude of the shift seen in the Republican Party in recent years is unusual. This trend aligns with former President Trump's frequent claims that U.S. elections are corrupt. Thad Kousser, a co-director of UC San Diego's Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections, stated that many people remain unconvinced they can trust the system, noting that these individuals are predominantly located within one political party.
Despite the partisan divide, a wide majority of Americans, representing 66 percent, believe the midterms were fair. This represents an improvement from pre-election sentiments, when less than half of U.S. adults expected the contests to be free and fair. However, this overall increase in trust was driven largely by Democrats and independents, many of whom had feared federal interference at the polls that ultimately did not occur.
Lauren Prather, also a co-director of the UC San Diego election center, cautioned against interpreting the 66 percent approval rating as a sign of universal confidence. She argued that the aggregate number obscures the significant partisan gap in how the election is perceived. The widespread doubt among Republicans serves as a reality check for those questioning whether Trump's style of election denial has lost its momentum in American politics.
The number of politicians who deny or question election results is expected to decrease next year. Furthermore, the vast majority of election-denying candidates who ran for positions involved in overseeing statewide elections lost their races this year, according to tracking by the advocacy group States United Action. Election experts have also noted that Trump and other high-profile losing candidates conceded their losses, a development that was widely celebrated.
On election night, as it became clear that Democrats would retake the House and Senate, Trump told Fox News' Bret Baier that he would accept the results, asking, "Why wouldn't I?" However, just days later, he began questioning those same outcomes, posting online to ask if anyone really believed the election was honest. The new polling suggests that there is still a receptive audience for such claims among Republicans.
When asked whether politicians discuss voter fraud too much, too little, or just the right amount, only 15 percent of Republicans answered that it is discussed too much. Kousser explained that there is both demand from the Republican base for continued focus on this issue and a supply from politicians who continue to provide it. As long as these two dynamics exist, he said, there will remain a market for these concerns.
In most elections, both domestically and internationally, supporters of the losing party typically experience a dip in trust. Kousser compared this to asking fans if they trust the referees after an overtime basketball game. However, he noted that in an ideal scenario, this oscillation would be around 10 percentage points in either direction, rather than the 30-point swing observed among Republicans between 2024 and 2026.
Despite the recent drop in confidence, the current numbers still represent an improvement from 2020. Leading up to the January 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol, just 22 percent of Republicans said they had confidence in the nationwide vote count, according to similar polling conducted by MIT's Election Data and Science Lab.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






